Page tree

Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

Date

08/22/2016

1800 UTC

 

GoToMeeting Details

https://global.gotomeeting.com/join/374912925

 Use your microphone and speakers (VoIP) - a headset is recommended. Or, call in using your telephone.

Dial +1 (872) 240-3212
Access Code: 374-912-925
Audio PIN: Shown after joining the meeting

Meeting ID: 374-912-925

Apologies

Objectives

  • Obtain consensus on agende items

Discussion items

ItemDescriptionOwnerNotesAction
1Call to order and role callJCA

 

 

2Approval of 20160627 minutesJCA 
  •  Approve minutes from 06/27/2016

5Requirement for description matching FSN in MRCMJCA

Summary of previous discussion: (see 2016-01-22 Editorial AG Conference Call)

  • Current FSN naming conventions result in "non-user-friendly" descriptions. Creation of another description without the semantic tag adds no value
  • Many existing FSNs would be ambiguous without the addition of the semantic tag.
  • Users often do not request "preferred terms" so rely on editors to provide appropriate descriptions.
  • Historically, many FSNs were glorified preferred terms
  • This is an issue that only affects English versions as translation provide terms of use in their languages
  • Challenge to editors is when to create a different preferred term if the FSN term is not user-friendly.
  • This has an impact on acceptance of word order variants as preferred terms.

Assumptions:

  • Semantic tags provide value in disambiguating concepts in different hierarchies with the same description (e.g Swab (physical object) vs. Swab (specimen))
  • Current FSN naming conventions do not always provide user friendly descriptions, so duplication of these descriptions adds no value.
  •  Consensus on options: 1) require matching description (SCA give error) or 2) matching description optional (SCA gives warning)
  •  Bruce Goldberg To take this naming issue back to the ECE for discussion and recommendation.
6Action item reviewEAG

Space Actions

Not addressed at this meeting due to time constraints

 
7Potential agenda topics for Wellington meetingJCA

We are meeting for a full day in New Zealand. Need substantive topics to move forward.

 

  •  Solicit additional agenda topics for Face-to-face meeting
8September conference call date and time verificationJCA

JCA is traveling Sept 10-23. Meeting scheduled for Sept 26

 

 
9Additional itemsEAG  

Meeting Files

 

Meeting minutes

2016-06-27 Editorial AG Meeting Minutes