Content Managers Advisory Group

Page tree

Summary

This proposal highlights 255 concepts of the 2794 descendants of 418019003 |Accidental event (event)| that seem appropriate to inactivate. There may be others with similar issues that have yet to be reviewed. 

These concepts appear to be classification constructs and use:

  • negation via the use of the term “except”,
  • excessive pre-coordination,
  • “or”,
  • nonsensical descriptions.

The CMAG is being asked if inactivation of these concepts will cause an issue for any members. 

IHTSDO-1071 - Getting issue details... STATUS

Actions: 

DateRequested actionRequester(s)Response required by:Comments
 Requested 11th April 2018Please advise if inactivation of this content would cause an issue for your country.

 Cathy Richardson, Krista Lilly

  • Camilla Wiberg Danielsen  Please advise if inactivation of the identified subtypes of Vehicle accident (event) as noted in the content tracker IHTSDO-1071 would cause an issue for your country.
  • Daniel Karlsson  Please advise if inactivation of the identified subtypes of Vehicle accident (event) as noted in the content tracker IHTSDO-1071 would cause an issue for your country.
  • Elaine Wooler  Please advise if inactivation of the identified subtypes of Vehicle accident (event) as noted in the content tracker IHTSDO-1071 would cause an issue for your country.
  • Elze de Groot  Please advise if inactivation of the identified subtypes of Vehicle accident (event) as noted in the content tracker IHTSDO-1071 would cause an issue for your country. 
  • John Fountain  Please advise if inactivation of the identified subtypes of Vehicle accident (event) as noted in the content tracker IHTSDO-1071 would cause an issue for your country. 
  • Linda Parisien  Please advise if inactivation of the identified subtypes of Vehicle accident (event) as noted in the content tracker IHTSDO-1071 would cause an issue for your country. 
  • Matt Cordell  Please advise if inactivation of the identified subtypes of Vehicle accident (event) as noted in the content tracker IHTSDO-1071 would cause an issue for your country.
  • Olivier Bodenreider  Please advise if inactivation of the identified subtypes of Vehicle accident (event) as noted in the content tracker IHTSDO-1071 would cause an issue for your country.
  • Jostein Ven  Please advise if inactivation of the identified subtypes of Vehicle accident (event) as noted in the content tracker IHTSDO-1071 would cause an issue for your country.
  • Johannes Gnaegi  Please advise if inactivation of the identified subtypes of Vehicle accident (event) as noted in the content tracker IHTSDO-1071 would cause an issue for your country.
  • Theresa Barry  Please advise if inactivation of the identified subtypes of Vehicle accident (event) as noted in the content tracker IHTSDO-1071 would cause an issue for your country.
Please post your final responses in the Country response table below. Discussion comments can be made as comments.

 

Relevant documents

  File Modified
Microsoft Powerpoint Presentation CMAG Transport Accidents 20180411.pptx 2018-Apr-10 by Cathy Richardson

 

Actions

  • Type your task here, using "@" to assign to a user and "//" to select a due date

Country response 

CountryDateResponse
 US 20APR2018

 OK in principle to remove nonsensical content.

The excessive pre-coordination dogma does not have to be invoked here (and should probably be put to rest – the only thing that matters is the right level of pre-coordination, as required by use cases. This is a bit of a personal crusade, but I think it is good to reaffirm once in a while.)

Unclear how this could impact analytics, but probably very little if these concepts are nonsensical to start with.

 Sweden 2018-04-23No content <<418161006 |Vehicle accident (event)| in out extension nor in any maintained or in-development refsets. Go ahead! 
 Denmark2018-04-25 Not in use in Denmark. 
 UK 2018-04-30 In principle inactivating this content will not cause any issues. However to faciliate data repair we would like to see these inactivated with a MAYBE A relationship or similar.
 NZ 2018-05-01 No objections raised in New Zealand
 AU2018-05-03

 As mentioned elsewhere, we fully support retiring these concepts. Although the initial item seems to be to address the mapping issues, a larger task should also be undertaken to remove all similar concepts in both event and finding hierarchies. Sometimes it's not even clear what role the subject of record would have in a concept:
215606001|Submersion or drowning due to being thrown overboard, water skier injured (event)| - is the subject the person who fell overboard and drowned? or the skier (that presumably crashed into the person who fell overboard?)?

216234009|Poisoning caused by carbon monoxide from aircraft while in transit, without accident to aircraft, occupant of spacecraft injured (disorder)|
215722007|Injury in water transport caused by laundry machinery, water skier injured (disorder)|

CA 2018-05-04 Not in use in Canada.
   
Member countries without a CMAG rep  

 

CMAG response

DateCMAG ResponseNext steps
   
   
   

 

Final outcome: 

Date: 

 

  • No labels