Date
2016-09-19 20.00 UTC
GoToMeeting Details
https://global.gotomeeting.com/join/201313901
Having trouble starting the meeting. Stay tuned...
Apologies
Previous Meetings
| Title | Creator | Modified | |
|---|---|---|---|
| E2O meeting 20220825 | Daniel Karlsson | 2022-Aug-25 | |
| 2022-05-23 - OBSERVABLE Meeting | Daniel Karlsson | 2022-May-24 | |
| E2O meeting 20220504 | Daniel Karlsson | 2022-May-05 | |
| 2022-04-25 - OBSERVABLE Meeting | Daniel Karlsson | 2022-Apr-26 | |
| 2022-04-06 - OBSERVABLE Face-to-face Meeting | Daniel Karlsson | 2022-Apr-25 | |
| 2022-03-21 - OBSERVABLE Meeting | Daniel Karlsson | 2022-Mar-31 | |
| E2O 23rd meeting 20220223 | Daniel Karlsson | 2022-Feb-23 | |
| 2022-02-21 - OBSERVABLE Meeting | Daniel Karlsson | 2022-Feb-22 | |
| E2O 22st meeting 20220202 | Daniel Karlsson | 2022-Feb-02 | |
| 2022-01-24 - OBSERVABLE Meeting | Daniel Karlsson | 2022-Jan-24 | |
| 2021-12-20 - OBSERVABLE Meeting | Daniel Karlsson | 2021-Dec-20 | |
| 2021-11-15 - OBSERVABLE Meeting | Daniel Karlsson | 2021-Dec-16 |
5 Comments
Xavier GANSEL
I am not skilled enough to give a good answer to the questions raised during last meeting by the slides of David Sperzel.
Nevertheless I understand the proposal
I would like to suggest that the group ask input to Stefan Schulz. He is likely to be one of the best skilled member in the domain.
May be we could also ask for some external advice to Barry Smith too. Of course this may create discussion / comparison with OGMS.
But having input / help form those 2 leaders will certainly be very valuable.
Daniel Karlsson
The top level ontologies were discussed when the model was developed, and were used to influence the model, and there is an BioTop-to-Observables bridge developed in cooperation with Stefan Schulz.
OGMS does not (signifcantly) overlap with the Observables model (and possibly presence is an area where the relationship is particularly unclear). I've talked to Barry (a tiny bit) about an ontology of health care observation and he realized the lack of any such work in the OBO community, e.g. the Ontology of Biomedical Inverstigation is geared towards research observations (I've discussed this non-overlap with Bjorn Peters). Also, Jim Campbell presented the Nebraska work using the Observables model at the ICBO meeting this week and directed Barry towards the Observables project. Stefan Schulz used to be active in the project but has not participated the last year, but I'm sure he would help if asked. So chances are we will get feedback from both in the near future.
Thanks,
Daniel
David Sperzel
I completely agree that it would be very useful to get as much input from Stefan Schulz and Barry Smith as they are willing to provide. Much of the information in my slides is based on publications from these two authors, but it's certainly possible that I got some things wrong. Whatever SNOMED CT ends up doing about representing observation results in the long run, I think we want to be sure that neither of these two experts considers it to be incorrect from a formal ontological standpoint.
David Sperzel
I have uploaded a revised version of the slides. This version contains some modeling examples, as Rob kindly suggested.
Scott Campbell
Jim Campbell recently presented the concepts of an observables ontology at Barry Smith's recent conference. I do suggest discussion with Jim before making any commitments/requests for information until you have had a chance to gets Jim's input.